Introduction

This section presents a structured account of observations made in the reef system surrounding Roatan, Honduras. This is not unique to this location but the conditions are consistent with other findings in the reef systems of the Gulf. These findings and identifications are based on personal experience and the efforts of amateur naturalists. These observations extend a continuing investigation into coral reef health, previously initiated in the post titled “Death in Paradise.” See past posts. This is presented is made to support my application to the Water School at Florida Gulf Coast University to study for a Master’s in Environmental Sciences. The goal is to learn more about coral reefs, coal polyps, and polyp disease.

These observations are findings revealed by white light flash photography during the day and ultra blue illumination lighting with amber filtration to show fluorescence at night. It was not possible to superimpose photos of identical structures due to instability caused by rough sea conditions.  

IMAGES WITH FLUORESCENT LIGHT

Figure 1: Fluorescent Green Goniopora Coral

Photographed using an ultra-blue light source and an amber filter, this image depicts a fluorescent green Goniopora coral, also known as the flowerpot coral. Under white light, these corals appear dull brown, but under blue or UV light, their fluorescent pigments—produced by dinoflagellate algae within the polyp—create a vivid green glow. This species is a Large Polyp Stony (LPS) coral, notable for long, fleshy polyps resembling a bouquet of flowers. The coral may belong to either the Goniopora or Alveopora genus, which can be differentiated by tentacle count—Goniopora polyps have 24 tentacles, while Alveopora have 12. 

---

Figure 2: Tubastraea faulkneri (Orange Cup Coral)

This image, also captured with ultra blue lighting and an amber filter, shows a coral likely to be Tubastraea faulkneri, the orange cup coral. Typically orange, this species may display green or yellow variations under specific lighting. Tubastraea faulkneri is a non-reef building LPS coral, often inhabiting cryptic environments such as caves, overhangs, and shipwrecks. Notably, it is a zooxanthellate carnivore, lacking symbiotic algae and feeding by extending its polyps at night to capture plankton. Its distribution spans the Atlantic Ocean and Caribbean Sea with origins in the Indo-Pacific.

---

Figure 3. Montastraea cavernosa (Great Star Coral)

This photograph features a coral with a bright green base and purple-rimmed polyps or tips, possibly a Neon Green Cyphastrea, Montastraea cavernosa (Great Star Coral), Goniopora, or Fimbriaphyllia (Frogspawn/Hammer coral).

---

Figure 4.

An image taken with blue light and an amber filter shows a central region of dead coral polyps highlighting loss within the colony.

---

Figure 5: Montipora Coral (“Shamrock Monti” or “Rainbow Montipora”)

This photo reveals a Montipora coral, recognized for vibrant green polyps on a purple or blue base under actinic lighting. As an SPS coral, it displays a bumpy, encrusting growth form and is valued by reef keepers for its resilience and fast growth. The coloration varies with lighting conditions, often intensifying under different spectrums.

---

Figures 6–8: Disease Progression in Montipora Coral

Figure 6 shows a Montipora coral under blue light. Figure 7, an enlargement, illustrates zones of normal tissue, dysfunction, and tissue loss, suggesting the possible progression of Stony Coral Tissue Loss Disease (SCTLD). Figure 8 highlights an encrusting Montipora structure glowing green under blue/UV light, with blue/purple areas indicating disease and tissue death.

---

Figure 9: Surviving Fluorescent Polyp Coral

This image depicts a fluorescent polyp coral barely surviving amidst lifeless surfaces devoid of reflective polyps.

---

Figure 10: WWC Electric Daisy (Stylocoeniella armata)

This specimen is a small polyp stony (SPS) coral, forming a dense, textured mat and known to compete with other corals upon contact. (often called a “thorn coral”).

---

Figure 11: Maze Brain or Worm Brain Coral

Likely a Platygyra or Favia species, these coral display neon green and purple fluorescence due to specialized proteins. It forms dome-shaped colonies with maze-like channels and can be semi-aggressive, extending sweeper tentacles at night. Nutrition is primarily derived from symbiotic algae.

---

Figure 12: Encrusting Montipora or Cyphastrea

This image shows an encrusting coral, possibly Montipora or Cyphastrea, with green and purple fluorescence. The coral spreads as a thick mat, but species identification requires microscopic skeleton examination.

images WITH White light with photoFlash

Figure 13: Mustard Hill Coral or Related Species

Using white light flash, this photo captures a yellow, bumpy stony coral, likely a mustard hill coral (Porites astreoides), star coral (Orbicella spp.), or brain coral. The coral features a massive, uneven surface covered in small polyps. An encrusting goup of organism is growing in the cavity of the stony skeleton devoid of polyps. These corals are native to shallow, warm Caribbean reefs and play a critical role in reef-building.

---

Figure 14: Diseased Brain Coral

This image shows a brain coral suffering from disease with evident demineralization and erosion.

---

Figure 15: Boulder Brain Coral (Colpophyllia natans)

This photograph shows Colpophyllia natans, a common and large brain coral in the Caribbean. The coral displays wide, meandering ridges and valleys with contrasting colors. Fine, narrow lines (septa) running from ridges to valleys help distinguish this species. Boulder brain coral forms massive colonies and is a dominant reef-builder in shallow environments. It is currently considered vulnerable due to climate change, acidification, and disease. The central area in the image shows disease-related polyp loss.

---

Figure 16: Symmetrical Brain Coral (Pseudodiploria strigosa)

This image likely features a Symmetrical Brain Coral, forming a dome-shaped colony with convoluted valleys and rounded ridges. The coral is yellowish-tan with darker areas, lacking the groove found in some related species. Pseudodiploria strigosa is widespread in Caribbean shallow waters, slow-growing, and foundational to reef habitats, supporting symbiotic algae (zooxanthellae) for photosynthesis.

Note the irregular loss of polyp growth on the surface of central and right side of the specimen. This is consistent with the result of spreading SCTL disease. Additionally, the adjacent coral is completely overrun by the opportunistic algae.

---

Figure 17: Lettuce Coral (Agaricia spp.) and Codium Macroalgae

The image features a ruffled lettuce coral (Agaricia spp.) (Agaricia agaricites or Agaricia tenuifolia} and green branching macroalgae (Codium). The coral forms undulating plates or branches, often yellow-green or brown. 

Substantial polyp loss and algal overgrowth are evident. The accompanying Chlorophyta Codium macroalgae, known as green sea fingers, have a distinctive branching structure absorb nutrients like nitrates and phosphates from the water. 

---

Figure 18: Field of Broken Coral

White light photography reveals an expanse of broken, lifeless coral, a few healthy finger corals, and one small fish.

---

Figure 19: Pillar Coral Disease Progression

This image of one of the pillar coral species shows a pattern of disease spread from the bottom to the top where the top appears relatively healthy in this daylight exposed photograph. The lower two thirds are bare of polyps. This area has been overrun by algae. 

---

Figure 20:

This image of a collective variety of stony corals in various states of disease progress.  A patch of polyp covered coral is on the lower left. Exposed stone is seen in the central area. The remainder is covered by several opportunistic algae species. The images in the distance are overrun by SCTLD and covered with algae.

---

Figure 21: Snakelocks Anemone (Anemonia sulcata/viridis)

The organism shown in Figure 21 is likely a Snakelocks anemone. This finding is new to me. It is an invasive species out of its eastern Atlantic / Mediterranean range. Its tentacles are long and flowing, colored green, grey, or light brown, and tipped with violet or pink. Symbiotic algae embedded in its tissues supply nutrients through photosynthesis. Predatory by nature, it uses stinging cells to immobilize prey, although its sting is mild for humans. There were no observable mutualistic anemone fish. This supports the suggestion that these are indeed invasive.

Figure 22: Chocolate Brittle Star (Ophiuroidea cinereum)

The organism in this image is likely a brittle star, endemic to the Gulf of Mexico and known as the Chocolate Brittle Star.

---

Figure 23 – 24: Finger Coral (Porites spp.)

This image displays a branching finger coral, common in the Caribbean, with short, blunt, finger-like lobes. Porites typically have thicker branches, while Porites furcata features thinner, rounded tips. Both can appear green, yellow, or greyish, with color and growth form influenced by habitat conditions.

This enlarged view of Figure 23 depicts relatively healthy coral with no signs of Stony Coral Tissue Loss Disease (SCTLD).

Conclusion:

All stony coral varietals seem to be subject to the same disease. The progress of the disease is unchecked and is advancing. The algae may be flourishing because of increased nutrients in the areas resulting from decomposing polyps and because they are optimizing an echo-niche left vacant by the polyps. The algae are not rebuilding the reefs. The fish population is also in great decline probably secondary to the degradation of the reefs.

Personal Commentary and Reef Health Summary

After thirteen dives across six reef sites in Roatan, Honduras, the overall impression was a declining reef system. Notably absent were turtles, large fish, sharks, lobsters, tunicates, and nudibranchs. The reef, once vibrant, now stretches for miles as broken, gray-brown expanses covered by algae. Invasive species observed included lionfish, a single anemone, Tubastraea faulkneri coral, and two spiny urchins. Only small fragments of some coral species persist, with no Elkhorn, Pillar, or Staghorn forms present and much of the previously widespread fluorescence now largely gone. While some sponges and fans remain, the images presented here document the few surviving patches of live coral polyps amid non-fluorescent, algae-covered stone skeletons.

Plan for remediation:

Problem Statement

The Stony Coral Tissue Loss Disease is relentlessly advancing and destroying the vital surface of the stony reefs. The cause of this disease is not yet discovered. This is a continuing catastrophic event. Work is in progress and includes maping, determining the progress rate and direction of spread. The causality and cure are not yet determined.

If you wish comment please use the form below

If you wish to participate in discussion please use the board.

If you wish to receive notifications of new posts please subscribe